Economist on "Aej applied response times"
What are they? To desk reject? To full response?
View ArticleEconomist on "What is the best?"
Empirical economics, applied economics journal, journal of policy modeling, journal of macroeconomics. From the best to the worst, order these journals based in its reputation.
View ArticleEconomist on "Journal of Corporate Finance vs Review of Corporate Finance...
1) Which one is of higher quality? 2) Which one counts more for tenure?
View ArticleEconomist on "Corrupt Editors/Co-editors/Associate Editors"
Let's have a list of corrupt editors, co-editors, and associate editors who have handled the papers of their coauthors, advisees, or colleagues. If these people are commonly known in the profession,...
View ArticleEconomist on "Critical Finance Review vs JFQA"
1) which one is of better quality? 2) which one counts more for tenure?
View ArticleEconomist on "Review of Asset Pricing Studies vs Critical Finance Review"
1) Which one is of higher quality? 2) Which one counts more for tenure?
View ArticleEconomist on "My feelings toward my own papers over time"
diminished. In fact, when I look at papers published years ago (even several at top 5) and several papers currently at R&R, I can't help thinking that they are actually crap, except for the very...
View ArticleEconomist on "JEBO turnaround"
Thinking about submitting, but it has a reputation for being slow. Any recent experiences?
View ArticleEconomist on "Home for short theory paper w/ quick turnaround time?"
TE and EL come to mind but my paper is probably not good enough for TE but could do much better than EL. Need to get at least R&R by the end of summer.Any suggestions?
View ArticleEconomist on "RFS - average time of review process"
Does anyone know how much is the average time that a manuscript is under review in RFS?
View ArticleEconomist on "JME needs a new POTUS"
The current POTUSes are ruining the journal. Bring on new faces.
View ArticleEconomist on "LRM Reg Monkey submitting to AER. Do I report stars***?"
From AER guidelines:"Please do not use stars to denote significance of estimation results. Just report the standard errors in parenthesis."Should I not report stars? And hope the referees will incur...
View ArticleEconomist on "AER, QJE and now what?"
Experimental bro here. Desk rejection at AER, very nice comments and very nice and fairly positive referee reports at QJE (though rejection due to not large enough advance to be suitable for QJE). Now...
View ArticleEconomist on "Thought piece on complexity"
Hi bros,I've got a good thought/more philosophical piece on complexity that sat for 18 months at a journal (two rounds of R&R) before I withdrew it. It just got dinged from JEBO because of lack of...
View Article