Economist on "Journal of Economic Theory (JET) first response time?"
Does anybody have any information as to the first response time for desk rejections and rejections with referee reports? Thank you!
View ArticleEconomist on "Meaning of "under editor evaluation""
Noob here. I am guessing this status in Elsevier means the manuscript has received referee reports and the editor is making a final judgement? Would this be correct?
View ArticleEconomist on "New journal: American Journal of Health Economics. Will it be...
press release:http://www.mitpressjournals.org/userimages/ContentEditor/1386170849150/AJHE_Press%20Release_Dec2013.pdfOnly person assigned is the journal's director. Will it compete with JHE or HE or is...
View ArticleEconomist on "IER experience?"
Submittwd 3 weeks ago, 1.5 weeks ago got email with MS number etc. But did not get a link like some journals have where you can track status with editor/under review etcAnyone with experience here know...
View ArticleEconomist on "GEB special issue"
What papers were accepted for the GEB special issue for Lloyd Shapley? Was the guest editor David Levine fair?
View ArticleEconomist on "Review of Financial Studies Revise and Resubmit"
Does that mean the paper is about to be accepted? What is the conditional probability?
View ArticleEconomist on "I recommended revise and resubmit"
The editor went against me and rejected. Sorry bro(ette)s, I tried.
View ArticleEconomist on "I never recommend revise and resubmit."
The endless revisions, infinite time to publication, the paper bloat, I hate it.Reject, accept, or accept conditional on minor revisions.Join me bros.
View ArticleEconomist on "Revision submitted 7 months ago... no response yet!"
This is ridiculous. And no, it's not a top 5 journal. It's a good field journal.
View ArticleEconomist on "Co-authorship in Economic History and Economics: Are We Any...
http://papers.nber.org/papers/w23404
View ArticleEconomist on "Referee recommendation: major / minor review"
As a reviewer, when do you recommend a major vs minor revision? What does it based on - complexity of revision / hours of work needed? How many hours? Or major means something you reckon can't be done...
View ArticleEconomist on "Advice needed: How to stop writing papers like a grad student"
I want to be a good writer. I try really hard when writing my papers. But to me, they always read like a grad student wrote them. I don't know why. What are the give aways that a paper was written by a...
View ArticleEconomist on "When I first submitted my paper for review"
I used to have hair ... 3 rounds of review later (and after a lot of waiting) this is not the case any more - needless to say the paper is still under review You motherf@ckers I want my hair back
View ArticleEconomist on "JME review time"
Please share your recent experience with Journal of Monetary Economics in terms of the first decision time. thanks
View ArticleEconomist on "Trump invents new economic principle "priming the pump" -...
The AER just accepted a recent a transcript of a tremendous Interview (very tremendous) form Donald Trump, in which he coins the phrase "priming the pump":"We are happy to accept this interview...
View ArticleEconomist on "I paid all that money for a submission fee for this?"
The referee report shows the referee didn't get past the second paragraph of the introduction. This is grossly unfair, especially since as a grad student money is tight. If you're going to reject my...
View Article