Economist on "2 months plus at QJE"
I read that median submission time at the QJE is one month. My paper has been under review for over two months (first time submitting there). Is this a good or a bad sign?
View ArticleEconomist on "Corrupt Editors/Co-editors/Associate Editors"
Let's have a list of corrupt editors, co-editors, and associate editors who have handled the papers of their coauthors, advisees, or colleagues. If these people are commonly known in the profession,...
View ArticleEconomist on "My paper is getting blackballed"
Rejection after rejection even though it's a very good paper. The referee reports are all subjective garbage. Not a single valid criticism yet.
View ArticleEconomist on "R&R - but what kind?"
I can't tell what this decision is from the editor's letter:"Based on the reviewers' recommendations, we cannot accept your paper in its present form. However, we are interested in receiving a revised...
View ArticleEconomist on "Rejected at JME in 2013 and then..."
finally accepted at JPE! Of course, the authors did great revising works... but it's a fantastic drama for them!!!
View ArticleEconomist on "RoF claims that the median turnaround time is about 50 days"
Yet when they sent me my decision after 90 days they commented on how I should be grateful for their quick response time.
View ArticleEconomist on "AEJ Applied Recent Issue"
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/app.7.1Good to see some diversity.
View ArticleEconomist on "Include all robustness checks in initial submission?"
I have done a huge amount of robustness checks. Should I submit all the tables in an appendix in my initial submission (there's no way the journal will want them all to be published), or can I say...
View ArticleEconomist on "Journal of international economics"
How long should one wait before asking for a status update or sending a reminder to the editor?
View ArticleEconomist on "On what day you hear back from journals"
Are Journals tend to send out decisions on Monday?
View ArticleEconomist on "I tend to get rejected by conferences and journals"
My current streak is 8 in a row.
View ArticleEconomist on "Strategic Behavior and the Environment"
Any experience with that journal? Kirk can you add it to the journals' list?
View ArticleEconomist on "RoF counts heavily for tenure in most finance departments"
I wish I could publish something there.
View ArticleEconomist on "I'm struggling to publish!"
I'm proud of the work I have produced but it's not getting the love. *sigh*
View ArticleEconomist on ""Under review" at QJE"
"Manuscript XXX is Under review. Your submission has been assigned to an editor."Does this mean I got passed the desk? Or, is this completely uninformative? It's been a few days...
View ArticleEconomist on "Differences between (Age Cohort dummies) and (Age+Age2）"
In regressions, when should I use 1)Age Cohort dummies (e.g., every 5 years) 2)Age+Age squared Thanks a lot,
View ArticleEconomist on "Corrupt Editors/Co-editors/Associate Editors"
Let's have a list of corrupt editors, co-editors, and associate editors who have handled the papers of their coauthors, advisees, or colleagues. If these people are commonly known in the profession,...
View Article