Economist on "All you complainimg about econ papers too long..."
I just submitted a 10 page paper to a top fieldInnovative, new, interesting results, and applications elsewhere possibleIts clean, crisp and to the point.So if it lands on your desk remember it doesnt...
View ArticleEconomist on "EER vs. GEB"
Both are arguably tier-2 journals, but both lower than the true tier-2. EER < JEEA/EJ, GEB < JET/TE. Both publish theory and experiment papers. Which journal is regarded as better?
View ArticleEconomist on "Games and Economic Behavior"
Would you say that it's a good field journal, or is it more than that—i.e., just below the top journals but not that far?
View ArticleEconomist on "Withdrawing an accepted paper"
I am in a dilemma. My paper has been accepted by a good journal but all the 4 referee reports are so positive and full of praise of the paper that I am seriously considering withdrawing it from the...
View ArticleEconomist on "VLRM asks me for data set: Da fuq I do?"
Let's say I published g00t more than 5 years ago. Today VLRM asks me via email for the data set. Guy wants to replicate my results. Says he cannot reproduce my results from the original sources I have...
View ArticleEconomist on "Examples of humor in econ articles"
I am considering throwing a couple funny comments into my article. I haven't come across much humor in published articles (including other sciences), does anyone know of any examples?
View ArticleEconomist on "What does "fast decision on your paper" means?"
Hi, I submitted a paper to a journal that claims to have a "fast decision on your paper" and it's been 4 months under review. Is it fine to write to the editor at this point? I now the "standard" is...
View ArticleEconomist on "Non P&P short AER paper"
How do people see it? <6 pages but is publish on regular AER.
View ArticleEconomist on "Solo authored vs. coauthored with seniors."
solo-authored JEEA vs. coauthored ReStud with seniors (one advisor plus advisors friend)Which one counts more for tenure? JM?
View ArticleEconomist on "EER or JEDC."
Paper relevant for both. I am leaning towards EER but JEDC is pretty decent as well, so I am not sure where to submit first. Paper just rejected from JMCB, but it was a close call.
View ArticleEconomist on "WRDS - Best output format?"
Different options:1) .txt 2) .csv 3) .xlsx 4) SAS 5) STATAAny suggestions bros?What is the best according to your experience?
View ArticleEconomist on "My strategy of submitting papers"
Submit to a low-tier journal1. if rejectedsubmit to another same tier journal2. if RnRwithdraw, submit highersame loop with 1 and 2eventually it will be accepted in a decent journal
View ArticleEconomist on "Sick of macro guys calling JME #6"
For me, JME is just one of field top journals, not #6 econ journal. You guys cannot compare JME with general-interest journals.
View ArticleEconomist on "I dont see how I can possibly make a lateral move"
1st year AP here. I ended up in this VLRM Department which I like and I think it was the right placement for me given my VLRM status. By the way, I managed to publish a couple of papers in good...
View ArticleEconomist on "Would a publication in IER hurt you?"
I just had a paper accepted in the Indian Economic Review? Will this hurt me?
View ArticleEconomist on "Strategies for submission"
Choose:Option 1. Finalize draft. Get into as many summer conferences as possible. Try to condense all comments into new draft. Submit.Option 2. Finalize draft. Submit.?
View ArticleEconomist on "International Journal of Central Banking"
Any experience with them? The response rate to my emails is zero. I already wrote them twice, once in summer and once in the fall. Are they always so slow?
View Article