Quantcast
Channel: Economics Job Market Rumors Forum: Research / Journals - Recent Topics
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15780

Gauss on "Highly correlated referee reports within journal"

$
0
0

Bros, while to some extent this is not too surprising sometimes I feel that wow this is too much. Let's say you submit your paper to 4-5 outlets and saw about 10-13 or so referee reports. After these rejections you send the paper somewhere else and each of the three referee start talking about something that no one ever mentioned and make a big fuss about it.

This happened to me multiple times and I find it interesting even though I am aware that this may be somewhat related to editor's referee taste.

Any similar stories?


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15780

Trending Articles