Quantcast
Channel: Economics Job Market Rumors Forum: Research / Journals - Recent Topics
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15780

Economist on "Always the same referee"

$
0
0

We are getting always the same referee for a paper.The comments she makes are largely wrong/unsubstantial and still she keeps recommending rejection.

it is quite unfair that only one person who may have her own agenda is dictating what happens to a paper over an over again.

We have a pool of possible people we think this person may be but are not 100% sure of the precise identity.

What should we do? Any suggestion?


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15780